Skip to content
ZHAIBIANHuman Wisdom Archive⌕

Human Questions

What Is the Evidential Problem of Evil?

The evidential problem of evil argues that the amount or character of suffering makes an all-good, all-powerful God less likely.

Quick Answer

The evidential problem of evil says that suffering need not make God logically impossible to make an all-good and all-powerful God improbable. It emphasizes apparently gratuitous suffering: suffering for which we cannot see a justifying good.

eviltheodicyreligious epistemology

Key Takeaways

  • ✦It is probabilistic, not a claim of contradiction.
  • ✦It focuses on the scale, distribution, and apparent pointlessness of suffering.
  • ✦Replies include theodicies, skeptical theism, and revisions to divine attributes.

Question

How is an evidential argument from evil different from a logical one?

Quick Answer

It argues that observed suffering counts against theism as evidence; it does not claim that God and evil are formally inconsistent.

The Argument from Apparently Gratuitous Suffering

The argument begins with cases of suffering that seem excessive or unrelated to any greater good. If a perfectly good and powerful God exists, the critic says, such cases are surprising. The conclusion is typically comparative: suffering lowers the probability of theism relative to alternatives.

Why 'Apparently' Matters

The word marks an epistemic limit. We may not know every consequence of an event, but the critic argues that this ignorance cannot automatically neutralize ordinary moral and evidential judgment. The debate turns on what follows from not seeing a reason.

Main Replies

Theodicies propose goods connected with freedom, soul-making, or regular natural order. Skeptical theism says human cognitive limits make inferences from 'we see no reason' to 'there is no reason' unreliable. Critics respond that this reply may weaken too many ordinary judgments.

Learning Path

Part of a Structured Collection

◈

Religion, God & the Sacred: The Philosophy of Religion Learning Path

A structured learning path through the philosophy of religion: from the philosophy of God and the problem of evil to atheism, faith, religious experience, miracles, prayer, sin, and the sacred.

Continue learning path →

Continue Learning

Knowledge Network

Next Step

Continue your learning path

Archive references

Sources

2 scholarly sources
✓

Source and quality checks completed

Quality check completed 2026-08-23

◈Based on 2 scholarly sources◈Last updated 2026-08-23
Editorial Standards →Methodology →Corrections →