Archive Record · Wisdom Topic
Evil: The Philosophy of Suffering & Wickedness
Explore the philosophy of evil through Augustine, Aquinas, Hume, and Hick: the problem of suffering, theodicy, moral evil vs natural evil, and whether God and evil can coexist.
A curated topic hub for the philosophical study of evil and suffering, connecting the classical problem of evil with contemporary theodicy, the free will defense, and the distinction between moral and natural evil.
Archive navigation
Topic Knowledge Map
Topic
Evil: The Philosophy of Suffering & Wickedness
Philosophies
Questions for further inquiry
Key Questions
What Is the Free Will Defense Against the Problem of Evil?
The free will defense, developed by Alvin Plantinga, shows that God and evil are logically consistent by way of creaturely freedom. Trace the argument, its relation to Mackie's logical problem, and the main objections.
answer
What Is the Problem of Evil?
The problem of evil argues that the existence of evil is incompatible with an all-good, all-powerful God. Trace the logical and evidential versions, Mackie's formulation, and the main theistic replies.
answer
What Is a Theodicy?
A theodicy is a justification of God's goodness in the face of evil. Trace the term's Leibnizian origin, the main types (Augustinian, Irenaean, soul-making), and the difference between theodicy and defense.
answer
Ideas that shape the theme
Wisdom Concepts
Evil: The Wisdom of Confronting Darkness
Evil wisdom is the courage to confront darkness honestly — not explaining suffering away but facing its reality and finding meaning within it. From Augustine's free will defense to the silence of Job, this is the wisdom of refusing easy answers.
wisdom
God: The Wisdom of the Divine
God wisdom is the philosophical contemplation of the divine as the ground of being and the mystery of existence itself — the human search for ultimate meaning that runs through every tradition, from Aquinas's five ways to the silence of the mystics.
wisdom
Voices in the archive
Important Thinkers
Alvin Plantinga: Reformed Epistemology & the Free Will Defense
An evidence-led introduction to Alvin Plantinga, the American philosopher whose Reformed epistemology argued that belief in God can be properly basic, and whose free will defense transformed the problem of evil.
thinker
John Hick: Theodicy, Religious Pluralism & Soul-Making
An evidence-led introduction to John Hick, the British philosopher whose Irenaean theodicy reframed evil as soul-making and whose later work pioneered religious pluralism and the hypothesis of the Real an sich.
thinker
Augustine of Hippo
Augustine of Hippo (354-430) was a North African bishop and philosopher whose synthesis of Christian theology with Greek philosophy shaped Western thought for over a millennium.
thinker
Thomas Aquinas
A comprehensive introduction to Thomas Aquinas, the thirteenth-century Dominican philosopher whose synthesis of Aristotelian philosophy with Christian theology shaped Western intellectual life for centuries.
thinker
David Hume
Scottish philosopher whose empiricist investigation of knowledge, causation, and morality reshaped modern philosophy and provoked Kant's critical turn.
thinker
Immanuel Kant
German philosopher whose critical philosophy revolutionized epistemology, ethics, and aesthetics through systematic accounts of reason, experience, and moral duty.
thinker
Primary and enduring texts
Classic Books
The City of God by Augustine of Hippo
An evidence-led guide to Augustine of Hippo's The City of God: the monumental meditation on the two cities, providence, evil, and the foundations of Christian philosophy in the twilight of the Roman Empire.
book
Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion by David Hume
An evidence-led guide to David Hume's Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion: the classic critique of the design argument, the problem of miracles, and the limits of empirical reasoning about God.
book
Traditions for comparison
Related Philosophies
Philosophy of Evil
An introduction to the philosophy of evil: the logical and evidential problems of evil, theodicy, the free will defense, natural vs moral evil, and the soul-making approach, from Augustine to Plantinga and Hick.
philosophy
Philosophy of God
An introduction to the philosophy of God: the existence of God, divine attributes, the nature of divine action, and the coherence of theism, from Aquinas and Anselm to Swinburne and Plantinga.
philosophy
Ethics
An introduction to ethics, the philosophical study of morality, examining its central questions, major traditions, and the thinkers who shaped our understanding of how to live and act.
philosophy
Philosophy of Religion
Philosophy of religion is the philosophical examination of religious claims, concepts, and practices, including arguments for God's existence, the problem of evil, and the nature of faith.
philosophy
Quotation archive
Wisdom Passages
“Men are so made that they are capable of attaining, through their own free responses, the greatest possible individual and personal fulfilment... The world is not a paradise of hedonistic happiness... but a place of soul- making, in which the human person, through the discipline of moral effort, through struggle and suffering, may be brought from the self-centredness of primitive human nature to the other-centredness of the fulfilled child of God.”
“Two loves, then, have given rise to two cities: the earthly city, which is created by a love of self, even to the point of contempt for God; and the heavenly city, which is created by the love of God, even to the point of contempt for self.”
Curated collections for deeper study
Learning Paths
Religion, God & the Sacred: The Philosophy of Religion Learning Path
A structured learning path through the philosophy of religion: from the philosophy of God and the problem of evil to atheism, faith, religious experience, miracles, prayer, sin, and the sacred.
collection
Ethics & Moral Wisdom
A structured learning path through moral philosophy, from the great ethical theories of duty, utility, and virtue to the practical art of making ethical decisions in everyday life.
collection
Explore Related Topics
Knowledge NetworkNext Step
Continue your learning path
- philosophy
Philosophy of Evil
Related through Philosophy Of God
- topic
Sin: The Philosophy of Moral Failure & Redemption
Related through Philosophy Of Evil
- quote
Hick on Soul-Making: The World as a Place of Moral Growth
Related through Philosophy Of Evil
- wisdom
Evil: The Wisdom of Confronting Darkness
Related through Philosophy Of Evil
- topic
Atheism: The Philosophy of Non-Belief
Related through Philosophy Of Evil
- philosophy
Philosophy of Atheism
Related through Philosophy Of Evil
- topic
God: The Philosophy of the Divine
Related through Philosophy Of Evil
- answer
What Is a Theodicy?
Related through Philosophy Of Evil